Let's Talk

The Cracker Barrel Misstep: What Happens When Brands Skip the Data

Everybody is talking about Cracker Barrel, but here’s what they’re not saying…

This uproar wasn’t inevitable. It wasn’t even about “change” itself. It was about making a brand shift without understanding the true brand history, meaning, and loyalty it holds for its public.

When brands like Cracker Barrel rush into changes without doing the groundwork, they forget one thing: brands don’t belong to the boardroom; they belong to the people.

Here’s the misstep: instead of surveying actual Cracker Barrel diners (the ones filling booths on a Saturday morning, not just a digital sample pulled from a trendy panel), the brand pushed a change that clashed with the very essence of what their loyal audience associated with them.

And let’s be clear, this isn’t political. This is about brand stewardship. It’s about tapping into what your audience believes and values, across lines, and building from that shared meaning.

If they had spent even a week gathering real data: interviews at the restaurants, in-person surveys, testing perceptions, the results would have been a roadmap for what could (and couldn’t) shift without backlash.

At The Scale Society, we would have approached it differently:

  • Listen before leaping. On-site surveys and digital listening to capture real sentiment from their public.
  • Brand archeology. A deep dive into brand history and customer rituals to understand the soul of the brand before altering its expression.
  • Scenario testing. Controlled messaging tests to see where pushback or misunderstanding arises—before it becomes a PR fire.
  • Data-backed decisions. Strategy rooted in the right statistics, not assumptions.

Now, here’s the nuance: in today’s marketing world, stirring outrage is sometimes intentional. We’ve all seen brands launch controversial campaigns designed to go viral through anger. But let’s be real—this wasn’t that. Cracker Barrel didn’t play the outrage card; they simply flunked brand stewardship.

The lesson? Your audience will always tell you what the brand means if you take the time to ask.

Most brand failures aren’t about creativity—they’re about skipping the data. Don’t let your next move turn into a misstep.

👉 Work with The Scale Society to build a rebrand or campaign that resonates with your true audience and scales with certainty. [Start here →] http://thescalesociety.us/apply